Living in New England, our Ren Faire season is unfortunately coming to a close. While the end is bittersweet, I find myself thinking, “How can I make myself look even cooler next year?” Which, to me, is just about as exciting as all the other parts of a renaissance faire.
My wallet is not necessarily a fan of my fondness for fashion.
Still, I’ve managed to source a few options, and will likely have this as a sort of ongoing series, in which I find the best and most affordable (and ethical!) options for looking cool af at the faire.
TBH, finding Renaissance Faire gear that’s both ethically made and budget-friendly can feel like a quest in itself. A lot of mass-produced costumes aren’t built to last, and the items that are well made often make me want to crumble into an existential capitalistic panic about just how expensive they are.
The good news? There are makers and shops that produce durable, historically inspired pieces with responsible sourcing — and they won’t empty your coin purse. Unless you let them, which…fair.
Below is a curated list of some of the best places to shop for ethical, high-quality, affordable ren faire gear.
I’ve also linked some of my personal favorite items from each shop, so you can get an idea of the absolute gems they offer!
What “Ethical Gear” Means in Ren Faire Shopping
When I say ethical, I’m looking for shops that follow at least one of these practices:
- Small-batch or artisan manufacturing
- Fair labor practices
- Natural or sustainably sourced materials
- Transparent production
- Long-lasting craftsmanship
These are not fast-fashion costume factories. These are real craftspeople and responsible businesses making gear built for multiple faire seasons.
Top Websites for Ethical, High-Quality, Affordable Ren Faire Gear
1. Armstreet
Best for: Clothing, armor, footwear, accessories
Price Range: $$ – $$$
Why it’s ethical: ArmStreet designs and produces all of their items in-house, using small workshop production. Their pieces are built to last years, not days.
Why it’s affordable: While not “cheap,” their quality-to-price ratio is excellent. You get artisan craftsmanship for far less than equivalent custom tailoring.
Why I recommend it: If you want durable, historically inspired clothing that survives multiple festivals, ArmStreet is one of the most reliable options.
Personal Favorite: Check out this gorgeous Short Linen Overdress! Armstreet often has great sales, with this piece going for under $200.
2. Etsy (Independent Makers)
Best for: Leatherwork, jewelry, belts, cloaks, hats, custom items
Price Range: $ – $$ (varies by shop)
Why it’s ethical: You’re supporting small makers directly. Most Etsy sellers handcraft their items, use reclaimed or responsibly sourced materials, and operate transparent solo or family-run shops.
Why it’s affordable: You can find high-quality artisan items at competitive prices, especially from smaller shops that don’t have big marketing overhead.
Tip: Search for terms like “handmade leather ren faire,” “faire garb,” “LARP gear handmade,” and filter by location if you want to support local artists.
Personal Favorite: Too many to choose from here, but here’s a pic of me (and my partner!) in chainmail purchased from JosayChainmaille on Etsy! I also recommend checking out French Meadows, I don’t currently (Muahahahaha) own any of her pieces but they are so dreamy! Her shop can be found through the link or on Etsy under the same name.)
3. Faire Treasures
Best for: Women’s clothing, chemises, skirts, corsets, pirate-wear
Price Range: $ – $$
Why it’s ethical: Many items are handmade, and the shop focuses on slow-fashion, limited-production runs.
Why it’s affordable: Their basics and accessories are priced comfortably for faire-goers on a budget, without sacrificing durability.
Why I recommend it: Their clothing is comfortable, flattering, and sturdy enough for all-day wear (which is a feat in itself at a summer faire).
Personal Favorite: This gorgeous Plum Chemise! (retailing on sale at $70 USD)
4. Medieval Collectibles
Best for: Entry-level gear, basic garb, starter kits
Price Range: $ – $$
Why it’s ethical: While this shop carries mixed suppliers, many of their pieces come from small European workshops and reputable garment makers.
Why it’s affordable: They offer a wide range of price points, including plenty of options for first-timers building their kit.
Why I recommend it: It’s a great spot to assemble a full outfit on a budget—especially if you need basics like shirts, trousers, belts, and boots. They also have a really great selection of larp (and decorative) weapons! Their prices often reflect those of Calimacil and Epic Armoury’s websites, but for those who wish to save time instead of ordering from multiple places, Medieval Collectibles just might be your best bet.
Personal Favorite: These sick (and practical!) Jackboots ($150 USD) And the awesome detailing on this sword: Edda Viking LARP Long Sword from Calimacil.
5. Historic Enterprises
Best for: Extremely accurate historical pieces (especially medieval)
Price Range: $$ – $$$
Why it’s ethical: They partner with traditional craftspeople and historically inspired workshops that prioritize quality materials and fair labor.
Why it’s affordable: Their prices are solid for true living-history-quality gear (which usually costs far more elsewhere).
Why I recommend it: If you value authenticity and durability, this is a fantastic mid-range alternative to high-end reenactment gear.
Personal Favorite: This Surcoat , which is literally what dreams are made of. The historical accuracy of these pieces makes it an absolute standout to me.
6. HolyClothing
Best for: Flowy dresses, tunics, skirts, and goddess-style garb
Price Range: $ – $$
Why it’s ethical: HolyClothing is known for its fair-trade practices, paying living wages to their artisans in India and producing garments in small batches rather than mass factory runs.
Why it’s affordable: Their pieces are surprisingly budget-friendly for the amount of fabric, embroidery, and craftsmanship involved, and they frequently offer sales that make building a full ren-faire outfit much easier on the wallet.
Why I recommend it: Their garments are comfortable, inclusive in sizing, and beautifully detailed — perfect for faire-goers who want a soft, flowing, fantasy-inspired look without spending a fortune.
Personal Favorite: I cannot talk about Holyclothing without talking about my absolute favorite piece of theirs, Demeter Maxi Dress. It’s flowy, it’s soft, it’s breathable, and it’s honestly so affordable for the quality of it. I’ve worn this to at least half a dozen faires (and sometimes just in my room, don’t judge me! It’s too gorgeous not to!) and it hasn’t faded or changed a bit.
How to Shop Responsibly Without Overspending
Here are a few tips to stay ethical and thrifty:
- Buy fewer, better pieces — quality lasts.
- Support small makers when possible. (Buying pieces while AT the ren faire is a great way to support creators and the faire itself)
- Choose natural materials (linen, wool, leather) for durability.
- Start with basics and add detailed pieces over time.
- Buy multi-use items (a good belt can go with every outfit).
CRAFT YOUR OWN PIECES! I cannot overemphasize this point. Not only will the piece be custom to your desires, you can make them so affordable, and trust me–the dopamine that comes with crafting is like none other.
Final Thoughts
Shopping for ren faire gear doesn’t have to mean choosing between expensive custom work (though one of these days I swear I’ll afford to!) and cheap, disposable costumes. The shops above offer thoughtful craftsmanship, fair production, and prices that honor both the maker and your budget.
Whether you’re a seasoned faire-goer or gearing up for your first adventure, investing in ethical pieces helps support artists and keeps your garb looking incredible for years.
If you have favorite shops that deserve a shoutout, feel free to share them. I love discovering new makers!
Leave a Reply